The Only Proposal Worth Writing Is the One That Pushes the Boundaries

Most proposal teams are caught in a paradox.

They work harder than ever, produce more than ever, and yet sound more like their competitors than ever before.

If you’re writing proposals the same way you did two years ago, you may feel confident in your process, but you’re unfortunately not being effective.

The market, the tools, and the audience have changed. We now compete in a world where every evaluator reads hundreds of pages of content that sound nearly identical, often generated or “enhanced” by AI, without great bid teams to properly check the output.

Your challenge is no longer compliance or completeness. It’s differentiation in a sea of sameness.

1. The Attention Economy Has Reached Proposal Management

Information overload has redefined how buyers process proposals. Evaluators now skim, scroll, and pattern-match their way through responses rather than reading every word.

That means your proposal doesn’t need to say more; it needs to say something worth reading.

Each section is a small argument about how your organization thinks, solves, and delivers differently. The job is more than simply presenting facts but making those facts meaningful.

2. Authenticity Is a Competitive Advantage

Many proposal teams still believe professionalism requires corporate detachment. The result is language that’s technically correct but emotionally vacant.

When I began my career in proposal writing, I mimicked senior colleagues who equated seriousness with success. The tone was formal, cautious, and lifeless.

When I stopped writing that way, when I wrote like a person again, something changed. Evaluators responded. They described the proposals as “the clearest” and “most engaging” they had seen ever in their careers.

Authenticity is not informal, my proposal friends. It’s clarity, confidence, and a human voice that respects the reader’s time.

If your proposal sounds like it was written to impress a review committee rather than persuade a human being, it’s not a good proposal.

3. Conviction Creates Credibility

Every company holds a set of convictions, like beliefs about how value should be created, how customers should be treated, or how problems should be solved. Conviction gives your message direction. But conviction alone can also be self-absorbed if it isn’t grounded in the customer’s priorities.

The key is overlap: the intersection between what your organization believes and what your customer values.

This overlap is where persuasion occurs. It’s where the customer begins to see your belief system as relevant to their goals.

Great proposals start in the customer’s world and pull them, gently, credibly, into yours.

4. Begin with One Message

Most teams begin proposal development by brainstorming win themes. But a collection of disconnected win themes is not a message.

Effective proposals begin with a single, coherent idea, the central claim your entire response exists to prove. Every section, every proof point, and every graphic should reinforce that message.

Equally important is defining the real audience. A message written for “the client” is too broad to resonate. Focus on the small group of 10–20 evaluators who will actually read your proposal.

When your message tries to appeal to everyone, it appeals to no one.

5. Trust Is Built Before the RFP

Trust is not created in the proposal. It is earned in every interaction that precedes it.

If your marketing, sales, and leadership teams have spent months communicating clear, consistent ideas to your target accounts, those stakeholders already associate your company with a point of view. They already recognize your language and see you as credible.

By the time the RFP arrives, your proposal should feel familiar, a continuation of an existing conversation, not a cold introduction.

In other words, proposals don’t generate trust; they leverage it.

6. Redefining Proposal Metrics

The incentives we create define the outcomes we achieve.

If proposal teams are measured by volume, such as how many RFPs they respond to, they will optimize for speed and throughput. The output may be high, but the impact will be low.

If teams are measured by win rate and revenue influence, behavior shifts toward selectivity, collaboration, and strategic storytelling.

Organizations should measure proposal success not by activity, but by persuasion. Did this document change how the buyer thought about their problem? Did it make them want to talk to us again?

7. Standing Out Requires Courage

In a competitive pursuit, incremental improvements rarely change outcomes. To stand out, you must take a risk your competitors won’t.

Consider including a one-minute video message from your CEO to the buyer’s executive sponsor. A direct, unscripted acknowledgment of shared goals can accomplish what pages of text cannot. You know, that thing called human connection.

8. The Proposal as a Mirror

The proposals your company writes reflect the organization’s self-awareness. They reveal whether you understand your audience, whether you can tell a coherent story, and whether you have the courage to stand for something specific.

AI will accelerate how proposals are assembled. But the parts that matter most, like judgment, empathy, conviction, remain human work.

The only proposal worth writing is the one that changes how your buyer sees the problem and reminds them a real person wrote it.

Practical Next Steps

1. Clarify your central message before drafting a single page.

2. Define your reader group. Write for the real evaluators, not the entire organization.

3. Replace corporate generalities with conviction. What do you believe? Say it.

4. Audit your metrics. Reward outcomes, not output.

5. Humanize your proposals. Add elements competitors won’t, like narrative, perspective, or direct leadership messages.

Stargazy Links

✸ Join the community ✸ Subscribe to The Stargazy Brief ✸ Explore proposal tech comparisons ✸ Follow Stargazy on LinkedIn